Succession representatives have a legal duty to act in the best interests of the estate, creditors, and heirs. However, some succession representatives breach their fiduciary duty by:
- Committing willful misconduct
- Acting in their own self-interest
- Failing to act
- Being incompetent
As an heir, you may sue if a succession representative breaches their fiduciary duty.
Six Possible Remedies If You Sue a Louisiana Succession Representative
Before you bring a lawsuit against a succession representative, it’s important to know the potential outcomes of your case. A successful lawsuit may result in one of the following remedies:
- An accounting. You may demand an accounting from the succession representative. If the court orders the accounting, the succession representative will share their accounting of the estate which can include citing the assets that were collected and distributions or payments that were made from the estate. The court may also order that accounting continues at regular intervals. The information learned from the accounting may assure you that the succession representative is fulfilling their legal responsibilities, or it may lead you to seek additional remedies.
- Conversion of an independent administration of the estate to an ordinary administration of the estate. The conversion may allow for additional oversight, and you may be able to seek additional remedies if you find cause to remove the succession representative, seek injunctive relief, or seek other relief from the court.
- Injunctive relief. The court may grant injunctive relief if you show that you suffered irreparable harm that can’t be remedied with money. Some things are just not replaceable. Therefore, the court may issue an injunction to prevent the succession representative from taking certain actions until the court decides the matter.
- Removal of the succession representative. You may have cause to remove the succession representative if that person is unqualified to serve as the executor, has a conflict of interest, breached their fiduciary duty, or is incompetent. Removal typically requires a court hearing, and you will have the burden of proving that the succession representative should be removed.
- Financial damages. You may seek monetary damages from the court if you suffered financial loss because of the succession representative’s failure to act with reasonable care. These situations may arise if, for example, the succession representative fails to maintain appropriate insurance on the property or fails to value the property accurately before selling it.
- Not paying the succession representative. Succession representatives typically get paid for their work. However, you may petition the court to reduce or deny payment to the succession representative if that person breached their fiduciary duties.
Your Louisiana estate litigation attorney will discuss all of the options with you and help you pursue the right remedies for your situation.
Call a Louisiana Estate Litigation Lawyer
Our experienced Louisiana estate litigation lawyers want to make sure that your loved one’s estate is handled with care. Your loved one and all of their heirs place a tremendous amount of trust in the succession representative. If you were hurt by the succession representative’s negligence, intentional actions, or incompetence, we encourage you to contact us today to learn more about your rights.
Each year, our skilled Louisiana estate litigators represent hundreds of heirs, and we have represented clients in all kinds of estate disputes. Our attorneys will thoroughly review all aspects of the succession. Then, we will advise you of your options to stop the succession representative and hold them accountable for any harm they caused.
We encourage you to contact us by calling or completing our online contact form to have us contact you, so that we can discuss your legal options and potential remedies.
|
Related links: |
The Legal Duties Every Louisiana Succession Representative Owes
A Louisiana succession representative — whether an executor named in a will or a court-appointed administrator — holds a fiduciary position of trust. The law imposes specific, affirmative duties on every person who accepts this role. The representative must promptly take possession of and protect the estate’s assets, preventing waste, dissipation, or loss while the succession is being administered. They must conduct a thorough inventory of all assets, properly valuing each item, and submit that inventory to the court. They must identify and notify all creditors through the legally required notice process, review creditor claims, and pay valid claims in the correct priority order before distributing assets to heirs. Throughout this process, they must maintain accurate records and provide regular accountings to interested parties who request them.
The duty of loyalty requires the succession representative to act solely in the interest of the estate and its beneficiaries — not in their own personal interest, and not in the interest of any particular heir at the expense of others. A succession representative who also happens to be an heir of the estate is particularly vulnerable to loyalty conflicts: they may be tempted to favor themselves in valuing assets, distributing personal property, or paying debts. The law does not prohibit a beneficiary from also serving as executor, but it requires that executor to set aside their personal interests entirely when performing their representative functions. Actions that benefit the executor-heir at the expense of other beneficiaries are disloyal and give rise to legal remedies regardless of the executor’s good faith belief that they were acting appropriately.
The duty to account is one of the most frequently violated succession representative obligations. Beneficiaries are entitled to receive a complete, accurate accounting of all assets received, all debts paid, all administrative expenses incurred, and all distributions made. A succession representative who delays providing this accounting, who submits incomplete records, who fails to explain discrepancies, or who refuses to respond to reasonable requests for information has violated this duty. The accounting obligation exists precisely because beneficiaries have no independent ability to verify what the representative is doing with estate assets — the accounting is the only window they have into the administration, and a representative who denies them that window is undermining their ability to protect their interests.
When and How to Take Legal Action Against a Succession Representative
Legal action against a succession representative becomes appropriate when the representative’s conduct causes or threatens to cause harm to the estate or its beneficiaries, and when less formal means of resolving the problem have failed. The first step in most cases is a written demand — a formal letter from the beneficiary’s attorney identifying the specific conduct complained of, the legal obligation that conduct violates, and the remedy being sought. A written demand serves multiple functions: it creates a record of the complaint and the representative’s response, it may resolve the issue without litigation if the representative corrects their conduct, and it may be required before the court will grant certain types of relief. A representative who ignores a formal written demand from an attorney has made the decision to litigate rather than comply — a decision that will be held against them in subsequent proceedings.
When a representative’s misconduct is ongoing and causing immediate harm — dissipating estate assets, refusing to account for missing funds, transferring property to themselves or a related party — emergency relief may be available. A court can issue an injunction ordering the representative to stop the harmful conduct, or can suspend the representative’s authority pending a full hearing on the merits. Emergency relief requires demonstrating that the harm is immediate and irreparable, that the petitioning beneficiary is likely to succeed on the merits, and that the balance of hardships favors granting the relief. Courts are more willing to grant emergency relief when the specific harmful conduct is clearly identified and when there is evidence that the harm will continue unless stopped.
The full range of legal remedies includes removal of the representative from their position, surcharge for financial harm caused by the breach of duty, disgorgement of any profits the representative derived from their misconduct, and personal liability for assets improperly distributed or dissipated. Removal is the most drastic remedy and is typically reserved for cases of serious or repeated misconduct, but courts will not hesitate to remove a representative who has demonstrated that they cannot or will not perform their duties faithfully. After removal, the court appoints a successor representative — either a person named in the will as a successor executor or a court-chosen administrator — to complete the administration. The removed representative remains personally liable for any harm caused during their tenure.
Protecting Your Rights When the Succession Representative Is Uncooperative
Beneficiaries who suspect that a succession representative is mishandling the estate often face a practical problem: the representative controls the estate’s records and assets, making it difficult to know exactly what is being done wrong. Louisiana law addresses this by giving beneficiaries specific rights to information — including the right to demand a formal accounting and the right to inspect estate records. When the representative refuses to provide this information, a beneficiary can petition the court to compel the accounting and to sanction the representative for the refusal. Courts take seriously a representative’s failure to account: it is one of the clearest signals that something is being concealed, and judges respond accordingly.
Discovery tools available in litigation — depositions, document subpoenas, requests for production of financial records — allow a beneficiary’s attorney to obtain information that the representative refuses to provide voluntarily. A forensic accountant who analyzes the estate’s financial records can identify discrepancies between the representative’s accounting and the actual financial activity in estate accounts. Expert witnesses who testify about the standard of care for succession representatives can establish that the representative’s conduct fell below what the law requires. Building this evidentiary record takes time, but it is often necessary when the representative is actively concealing misconduct rather than simply being negligent.
Timing matters when taking action against a succession representative. Louisiana’s prescriptive periods for claims against fiduciaries are shorter than those for general civil claims, and delay in acting can result in permanently losing the right to seek a remedy even for clear misconduct. A beneficiary who notices problems with a succession administration — an accounting that does not add up, distributions that seem inconsistent with what the will provides, estate assets that appear to be missing — should consult with a succession attorney as soon as the problem is identified. Early legal consultation allows the attorney to assess the situation, identify the applicable prescription period, advise on what steps to take immediately to preserve the claim, and potentially resolve the issue before it becomes more serious and more expensive to address.